Connor Storrie just earned his first Emmy nomination — but not for the role that turned him into one of the internet’s newest heartthrobs.

The 26-year-old actor received the nod Wednesday for Outstanding Guest Actor in a Comedy Series. That was for hosting Saturday Night Live earlier this year.

While many fans had hoped to see Storrie recognized for his breakout performance as Ilya Rozanov in Heated Rivalry, the queer hockey drama wasn’t actually eligible for the Primetime Emmys — because it was entirely financed in Canada.

Still, the nomination felt like a victory to fans, many of whom celebrated it as overdue recognition for an actor whose career has skyrocketed since Heated Rivalry premiered. Over the past year, Storrie has gone from breakout star to awards-season regular, appearing at the Golden Globes, making his Met Gala debut alongside co-star Hudson Williams, landing luxury campaigns with Saint Laurent and Tiffany & Co., and preparing for the show’s anticipated second season.

While Heated Rivalry couldn’t compete at the Emmys, it dominated Canada’s awards season, taking home 16 Canadian Screen Awards, including Best Drama Series. Because Storrie is American, he wasn’t eligible for an individual acting prize there either, making Wednesday’s nomination his first major acting nomination tied to the Heated Rivalry era, even if it came through an unexpected role.

This Tweet is currently unavailable. It might be loading or has been removed.

Fans were quick to celebrate the news, with many joking that the universe had found a loophole to honor the actor after Heated Rivalry was shut out of eligibility. They also declared they couldn’t wait to watch “Emmy-nominated Connor Storrie” return for Heated Rivalry Season 2.

This Tweet is currently unavailable. It might be loading or has been removed.

This Tweet is currently unavailable. It might be loading or has been removed.

The excitement also reignited calls for broader recognition of Heated Rivalry, with fans lamenting that one of the year’s most talked-about new dramas couldn’t compete at the Emmys because of eligibility rules rather than a lack of acclaim.

This Tweet is currently unavailable. It might be loading or has been removed.

This Tweet is currently unavailable. It might be loading or has been removed.

The moment also seemed like a full circle for the actor, who spent his adolescent years uploading videos to YouTube under the name “Actorboy222,” chronicling his ambitions of making it in Hollywood. On Wednesday, many pointed out that the younger version of Storrie had finally gotten the recognition he’d always dreamed about.

This Tweet is currently unavailable. It might be loading or has been removed.

Whether or not Storrie takes home the trophy, the nomination marks another milestone in what’s been a meteoric rise. With Heated Rivalry already renewed for a second season and production expected to begin soon — not to mention an A24 project in the works — fans won’t have to wait long to see him back on screen, Emmy nominee status included.